the king's affection review
Uncategorized

The King’s Affection Ep 1&2 Review: Subverting Tropes of Gender Bender Romance Dramas

Go Ara says in Miss Hamurabi, “there are no bad or evil people, just bad or evil situations.” But what about this situation?

A crown prince orders the death of his own infant daughter because the royal family can’t have a son who’s shared a womb with a girl. Especially since that son will someday be the king. Maybe my modern sensibility is impairing my objectivity here but I can’t help but feel that such a decision is evil and the one making it is evil. No matter what compelling reasons they tell themselves they have.

Much later in the drama when the young princess, who escaped death and doesn’t know her own identity, comes back to the palace as a maid and happens to meet her father, she is impressed with how kind and well spoken the man is. And the entire time I’m thinking that this is a man who – when ordered by the king to have his child murdered for the crime of being a girl – gave in. Didn’t protest. Didn’t trot out any of these wise philosophical sayings. Or make a compelling argument. This man is all words and no action. He’s not impressive. He’s just a coward.

You can probably tell that I’ve become very emotionally invested in The King’s Affection. This Park Eun-bin and Rowoon drama hooked me before any of the protagonists grew up into their adulthood.

I think a big reason for my absorption is the way the story subverts my expectations of gender bender historical romances. So, in this essay, I want to talk about three subversions that struck me hard.

The first was that we got to meet and know the young prince YI-HWI. The one whose place his twin sister has to take up later. He’s such a clever, sweet, and kind boy that when the inevitable moment of his death comes, I’m left… kinda devastated. It’s a credit to the show that they managed to flesh him out so much in just one episode. I felt like I knew what kind of King he might have been if he had a chance to grow up.

Which was surprising, because it would have been so easy to show the audience that his sister taking his place was a good thing. That she was a better choice.

It’s what a lot of stories that champion the competence of women have done. Instead of treating women as humans who’re as fallible and as brillant as men, we’ve had way too many stories  where a smart woman overthrows an incompetent man and happily ever after is had by all.

The King’s Affection chooses nuance and therefore tells a much more complicated and much more interesting story.

The second unexpected thing was the CROWN PRINCESS. The mother of the twins. She was aware that it was the machinations of her own father that resulted in the death of one of her children, so she squarely placed the blame where it should reside and focused on protecting everyone she could.

She’s clever, she clearly inspires loyalty, and she can think of the good of people around her without sacrificing anyone. If she had the power her husband did, and was ordered by the king to murder her child, she wouldnt have quietly given in. She would have fought and she did fight. As much as she could.

Reading the synopsis of the drama before it aired made me think that the prince dies of natural causes and a power hungry queen replaces him with his sister to save her own position. Which is the kind of plot I’ve definitely seen in historicals before. But instead it’s amazing how the drama shows the helplessness of someone stuck in the middle of a belief system that justifies infanticide, when all she wants is to protect the babies she brought into the world.

The final unexpected turn was the positioning of the gender bent heroine.

The drama has been subverting my expectations of what a historical gender bender romance can be like from the word go.

Usually the girl is disadvantaged and either trying to get an education or escape a situation by pretending to be a man. And then she meets someone powerful who falls for her without knowing that she’s a girl. Shenanigans ensue.

Instead you have a princess pretending to be her brother and growing up in a toxic environment where she constantly has to prove herself more ruthless and clever than her male cousins and uncles to keep her position in the hierarchy and herself above suspicion.

I think I expected Park Eun-bin’s king to show outward displays of kindness pretty early cause again that’s what gender bender romances do.

The girl shows the men around her how to be more sensitive and generous.

Instead this woman hunts stags and snakes, and bullies her eunuch. And Park Eunbin sells it. I can see her being a very hard-to-please prince.

Which of course makes me very eager to see her interact with Rowoon’s sensitive scholar in next week’s episodes.

Should be fun.

IN CONCLUSION, I am really enjoying the drama. This is how I like my fusion sageuks. High stakes, quietly subverting my expectations and face masks in the Joseon era. Seems legit. 

7 thoughts on “The King’s Affection Ep 1&2 Review: Subverting Tropes of Gender Bender Romance Dramas”

  1. Now you’ve got me excited about this! I love how Anisa said she’s going from Mr. Queen to Ms. King!

    It would be so subversive if they did her makeup the same way they did the dudes’ makeup (or give her a lack thereof), but this ain’t realism! LOL

    I will watch this only because of your review!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. We can only hope that Ms King has a better ending than Mr Queen. XD

      I’m loving the story so far, and the characters haven’t even all met in adulthood yet. Next week should be fun!

      Let us know how you’re liking it, Dr. Chi. ❤

      P.S. Once you watch it, head over to Patreon. I'm uploading a spoilery discussion episode about the first two episode there. It'll be publicly released on the podcast next week.

      Like

  2. I know how you feel as regards the “original” young prince, I kept waiting for him to get killed off but they kept making me like him more and more, I kinda hate them for that.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I feel the same way. Why did you make me think that I was going to get more time with this kid? Damn it. And he was such a sweetheart too. Choi Myung-bin (the child actor) totally blew me away. I resent that we have to move on to the grow up actors now. XD

      Like

    1. We see how Dam-i isolates herself and becomes aloof from everyone in the palace in later episodes, and also how it emotionally hurts her to become this person. She lives in a constant state of distrust, and that makes her existence miserable. =(

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s